"We were five different corporations working in five different directions," Steve Pappas told The Baltimore Banner, explaining why the family sold Pappas Seafood Co. this month. The buyer is Teamshares, a publicly traded firm based in New York City that buys small businesses and moves their ownership to employees over time. The price was not disclosed.
For Parkville, Steve Pappas's quote is the key detail. The company grew as several separate corporations, and the new owner's stated plan is to merge management and make the locations more consistent. The restaurant at 1725 Taylor Avenue came first, and every other location grew from it. Now it is the one being asked to line up with the others.
The original was a stag bar before it was a crab cake landmark
According to the Banner's obituary of Mark Pappas, he met his wife, Harriet, while running his uncle's lunch counter at a bus station. They married in 1963. In 1972 he took over a Parkville steakhouse and stag bar and renamed it Pappas Restaurant & Sports Bar. WBAL gives the earlier business's name as Wargo's Western Steak House & Stag Bar.
The crab cake started as an adapted recipe. The Banner reports that Mark Pappas took a recipe from fellow chef Tom Annos, removed the crackers, added more mayonnaise, and made the cakes himself for years. Its best-known fan is Oprah Winfrey, who found Pappas while she was living in Baltimore and working at WJZ. She has since posted about the crab cakes on Instagram. Mark Pappas died in November 2025 at 93, almost exactly a year before the sale was announced.
Over five decades, the Taylor Avenue restaurant grew into a group with five sites. These are the addresses Pappas lists:
- Parkville: Pappas Restaurant & Sports Bar, 1725 Taylor Avenue
- Cockeysville: Pappas Restaurant & Sports Bar, 550 Cranbrook Road
- Glen Burnie: Pappas Restaurant & Sports Bar, 6713 Ritchie Highway
- Bel Air: Pappas Restaurant & Sports Bar, 1225 E. Churchville Road
- Belair Road: Pappas Seafood Company Express Carryout, 8801 Belair Road. Pappas uses a Nottingham address, and the Banner describes it as the Perry Hall distribution facility that ships crab cakes to the restaurants and to customers.
The Parkville restaurant's contact page also lists a Pappas Crabcakes spot at MGM National Harbor, which the Banner does not count among the five. Even with crab cakes shipped from one Belair Road facility, Steve Pappas described the company as five corporations pulling in different directions, and the new owner has pointed to differences between the restaurants.
"Different French fries in each restaurant"
Teamshares has said where it will start. Eric Braunstein, its industry lead for food and beverage, told the Banner the firm will work to make Pappas more consistent across all five locations. His example was specific: "They have different French fries in each restaurant." Teamshares also plans to install a new president at Pappas and look for ways to raise profits. It has not named that president.
CBS News Baltimore heard the same thing from inside the company. Justin Windle, whom the station identifies as Pappas's general manager, said the purchase will merge management for all locations. Merged management under a new president, with consistency as a stated goal, means the Parkville, Cockeysville, Glen Burnie and Bel Air restaurants will be run more alike than they have been.
Here is what has been said about the change so far, who said it and where:
| Topic | What was said | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Leadership | Teamshares will install a new president; Steve Pappas advises until he retires, perhaps two years from now | The Banner |
| Management | Management for all locations will be merged | CBS News Baltimore |
| Menu | Consistency across all five locations, starting with the fries | The Banner |
| Ordering | Possible growth on third-party platforms like Uber Eats | The Banner |
| Prices | Crab cake prices could go up before they go down | The Banner |
| Staff | Health benefits and a 401(k) plan for employees | CBS News Baltimore |
The Pappas family still owns the Taylor Avenue building
Some things are staying with the family. Steve Pappas will keep owning the buildings at the Parkville and Perry Hall locations, the Banner reported. He will also stay involved in day-to-day operations and advise the new president until he retires. His brother-in-law, Justin Windle, stays on at the Cranbrook location. His sister-in-law, Karen Zimmerer, remains general manager in Perry Hall. "Of course, my name's on it, and I care about what happens," he told the Banner.
He also said why he made the sale public. According to the Banner, many businesses sell to Teamshares without announcing it. Steve Pappas wanted to stop rumors and reassure customers. "Not one place is changing at all," he said. "We have an investment group behind us now. That's how I look at it."
The ownership change itself plays out over decades. Teamshares gives employees a 10% stake when it buys a business. The business's profits then buy down Teamshares' shares and increase the employees' share. Madhuri Kommareddi, the firm's chief operating officer, told the Banner the goal is 80% employee ownership within 20 years, though that "really does vary depending on the company and its profitability." Teamshares was founded seven years ago, so none of its companies has reached the 80% mark yet. It owns more than 90 businesses, including the Don & Millie's fast-food chain from Omaha, Nebraska. Pappas is its first business in the Baltimore area.
Windle tied the timing to employees' needs. He told CBS News Baltimore that the opportunity arose about a year ago, when employees began thinking about retirement benefits after Mark Pappas's death. "The idea is to take the business from the retiring owner to turn it over to the employees who work hard for the company," he said. The health benefits and 401(k) that come with the merger were "not possible" under "a small, family-owned business," he added.
Where a Parkville regular could notice it first
The family's promise covers the dining room, and the building and familiar names back it up. The changes Teamshares has described would show up at the edges: how food is ordered, how it's priced and how closely it matches other locations.
Ordering is the clearest example. Steve Pappas told the Banner that Teamshares could help the restaurants grow on third-party apps like Uber Eats. "They would get a better rate because they have a national presence," he said. The Parkville restaurant's website links to an "Order Online" page. As of late October, that Toast ordering page for 1725 Taylor Avenue said it was not accepting online orders. If Teamshares follows through on its delivery plans, this is likely one of the first places the merger will show.
Price is the other one. Neither the family nor the buyers say price is fixed. The Banner ended its report with Steve Pappas warning that crab cake prices could go up before they go down. CBS News Baltimore reported that price is the one thing that may change, and said that depends on market conditions.
For now, the Taylor Avenue restaurant runs on the schedule posted on its website. Hours can change, so check before a special trip:
- Dining room: open daily, 11 a.m. to 9:30 p.m.
- Sports bar: 11 a.m. to 10 p.m. Sunday through Wednesday, and 11 a.m. to 11 p.m. Thursday through Saturday.
- Shipping: Pappas's shipping page says it ships nationwide, sending orders Monday through Thursday by UPS for next-day delivery. The online crab cake shop sells single cakes and multipacks. With the holidays coming, those Monday-through-Thursday shipping days decide when a package can go out to family out of town.
The Capital Gazette confirmed the sale on October 20, a day after the Banner's report. No changes have been announced at the Parkville restaurant, and the incoming president has not been named. The next concrete news will likely be that name.
Long-running local businesses like Pappas are part of what makes Parkville feel like home. Jennifer Bayne follows these changes because that's the part of a neighborhood a listing can't show. If Pappas comes up when you're deciding whether to stay, move or downsize, LivingMD is glad to talk it through with you. Let's Connect.